P08401: Water Desalination and Purification Device
/public/

Grading and Assessment Scheme

Deliverables
Grade Level MSD I MSD II
D A poor level of documentation was made by the end of week ten. The needs and concepts are not well reflected in the final outcome by the end of the first quarter. There is little evidence of Life Cycle Assessment and the improvement of the GE model for the satisfaction of the needs of low cost and availability stated at the beginning of the MSD course. A poor level of documentation was made by the end of the second quarter. The final product provides drinkable water but the lack of communication with the customer is reflected in the characteristics of the device. There are no signs of possible implementation.
C Documentation is disorganized and inefficient by the end of week ten. The needs and concepts are reflected in the final outcome by week ten. Lifecycle assessment is performed and even though redesign and materials choice took place, it does not fulfill quantifiable levels of LCA. Documentation is disorganized by the end of the second quarter. The final product cleans water but the materials chosen are not all low cost and it creates a problem for the future reproduction in the target market. Implementation has not occurred.
B Documentation is made but it is not complete until week 10. Good reflection of concepts in the final outcome by week ten. Streamed LCA is well performed, and a there is good justification of desig and materials choice. Communication with the customer could be better. Documentation is complete but not well organized by the end of week 20. Good reflection of the concepts in final product, which means the product provides clean drinkable water. Implementation is not finished, product might be delivered but training and maintenance issues are not clear.
A Complete and well organized documentation of the progress until week 10. Streamed LCA is very well performed, and a there is good justification of design and materials choice. The concepts are being well reflected on the results of the project by week ten. Communication with the customer is very efficient and there is a great understanding of his needs. Complete documentation of the progress until week 20. The final product provides clean drinkable water at a low cost while using it and througout the entire lifecycle of the product. The device is implemented and the customer is well trained and there are signs of strong networking for future references of maintenance and feedback.

Home | Planning | Concept Development | System Level Design | Detail Design | Testing and Refinement